Season 1

2021 · 26 episodes · 8h 30m in all · 9.0/10

1. It Couldn't Happen Here: Adel, Georgia
9 Sept 2021 · 45 min · 9.0/10
A man is charged with a brutal murder, will DNA evidence point to another man as the real killer?
2. It Couldn't Happen Here: Sauquoit, New York
16 Sept 2021 · 45 min
A local chiropractor is poisoned by someone she knows in a case that divides the whole town.
3. It Couldn't Happen Here: St. Augustine, Florida
23 Sept 2021 · 45 min
A young woman is shot to death with her police officer boyfriend's gun. Was it murder or suicide?
4. It Couldn't Happen Here: Cookeville, Tennessee
30 Sept 2021 · 45 min
In Cookeville, Tennessee a couple is executed in their sleep - but do police catch the wrong man?
5. It Couldn't Happen Here: Shelbyville, Kentucky
7 Oct 2021 · 45 min
An unlikely murder suspect is convicted of killing a man in rural Shelbyville, Kentucky.
6. It Couldn't Happen Here: Rockville/Ellington, Connecticut
14 Oct 2021 · 45 min
A club worker in Connecticut goes missing. A wealthy local businessman is suspected.
7
7. Indefensible: How Men Get Off
14 Oct 2021 · 20 min
On trial for his wife's murder, a man invokes a temporary insanity defense.
8
8. Indefensible: The Consent Offense
21 Oct 2021 · 20 min
A case of apparent murder by strangulation takes a shocking turn at trial.
9
9. Indefensible: A Few Bad Men
28 Oct 2021 · 20 min
When a man with a violent criminal history is paroled, tragedy quickly ensues.
10
10. Indefensible: The Panic Defense
4 Nov 2021 · 20 min
A chance meeting of strangers leaves one of them dead, and police struggle to answer why.
11
11. Indefensible: The Perfect Victim
11 Nov 2021 · 20 min
One woman escapes a serial killer, and the friends of another victim set a trap to catch him.
12
12. Indefensible: Helen & Olga
18 Nov 2021 · 20 min
Two elderly women get away with murder, but when they try it again, things don't go as planned.
13. It Couldn't Happen Here: Dallas, Georgia
1 Sept 2022
The investigation into a young mother's death divides a small town: was it murder or suicide?
14. It Couldn't Happen Here: Pocomoke City, Maryland
8 Sept 2022
A young single mother disappears without a trace. An investigation suggests she abandoned her children, while her family spends years proving she was murdered and finding her killers.
15. It Couldn't Happen Here: Angier, North Carolina
15 Sept 2022
In this True Crime Story, a man claims he shot his daughter's estranged husband, Chirstian Griggs, in self-defense. But after investigators close the case, Christian's family discovers evidence that the killing was not justified.
16. It Couldn't Happen Here: Iaeger, West Virginia
22 Sept 2022
Iaeger, WV. After a deadly fire, a man is imprisoned for murder. New evidence reveals the truth.
17. It Couldn't Happen Here: Atwater, Ohio
29 Sept 2022
Atwater, OH. Did an aggressive cold case investigation send an innocent man to death row?
18. It Couldn't Happen Here: Turlock, California
6 Oct 2022
Turlock, CA. An attorney known for uncovering corruption is accused of masterminding a murder plot.
19. It Couldn't Happen Here: Royse City, Texas
13 Oct 2022
A couple is brutally murdered in rural Texas - but did prejudice affect the investigation?
20. It Couldn't Happen Here: Edgewater, Florida
20 Oct 2022
A brazen daytime murder in Edgewater, Florida generates surprising unanswered questions.
21
21. Indefensible: Junk Science
27 Oct 2022 · 20 min
A debunked form of forensic science helps put a Florida man behind bars for life.
22
22. Indefensible: The Casey Anthony Episode
3 Nov 2022 · 20 min
A famous case with a controversial verdict poses questions about legal strategy and media coverage.
23
23. Indefensible: Stand Her Ground
10 Nov 2022 · 20 min
A Florida woman faces 20 years in prison for firing a warning shot.
24
24. Indefensible: Elephant in the Womb
17 Nov 2022 · 20 min
A Wisconsin woman goes to a hospital hoping to confirm her pregnancy and get medical help, but she instead finds she’s stepped into a nightmare. After being held captive for several days and denied a lawyer, she’s thrown in jail.
25
25. Indefensible: Concrete Ceiling
24 Nov 2022 · 20 min
A California woman who claims she was acting in self-defense ends up in prison for murder. While there, she finds her story is much more common than she realized.
26
26. Indefensible: Bye Bye Wozniak
1 Dec 2022 · 20 min
A senseless double murder lands a California man on death row. Despite this harsh sentence, a broken system surrounding the death penalty leaves everyone feeling justice hasn’t been served.